Rhinolophus namuli, Curran & Kopp & Ruedi & Bayliss, 2022

Curran, Michael, Kopp, Mirjam, Ruedi, Manuel & Bayliss, Julian, 2022, A new species of horseshoe bat (Chiroptera: Rhinolophidae) from Mount Namuli, Mozambique, Acta Chiropterologica 24 (1), pp. 19-40 : 26-36

Rhinolophus namuli sp. nov. Curran, Kopp, Ruedi, and Bayliss, 2022

Common name: Namuli Horseshoe Bat

2009 Rhinolophus sp. — Timberlake et al. (2008): Mount Namuli, Mozambique: biodiversity and conservation. Report produced under the Darwin Initiative Award 15/036. Pp. 60 and 110.

= this FA characteristics. in

species combined comparative related were Key closely which,. 2 genetically specimens

2010 Rhinolophus cf. maendeleo — Monadjem et al. (2010 b): Act. Chiropterol., 12: 371–391 — partim: Mount Namuli.

2010 Rhinolophus maendeleo — Monadjem et al. (2010 b): Bats of Southern and Central Africa: a biogeographic and taxonomic synthesis. Wits University Press, Johannesburg: 220–223, 560 — partim: Mount Namuli.

2019 Rhinolophus cf. denti / simulator — Demos et al. (2019). Molecular phylogenetics of the African horseshoe bats ( Chiroptera : Rhinolophidae ): expanded geographic and taxonomic sampling of the Afrotropics. BMC Evolutionary Biology, 19: 166.

ABLE T

Holotype.— Male adult (alcohol preserved, skull, baculum preserved in glycerol), MHNG 1971.068 (field collection number MZ 120). Mozambique, Zambezia Province, Mount Namuli, Ukalini saddle forest, below mountain peak, 15.369250°S, 37.061361°E ca. 1650 m a.s.l., 21 November 2008. Captured in 2-tiered harp trap set over a small stream leading to large clearing in montane forest, at ca. 18h00. Reference sequences of the mitochondrial CYT-B and COI genes issued from the holotype are deposited in the GenBank under accession numbers MZ936306 and MZ936310 , respectively.

Paratypes.— Male adult (alcohol preserved, skull, baculum preserved in glycerol), MHNG 1971.069 (field collection number MZ257). Mozambique, Zambezia Province, Mount Namuli, Ukalini saddle forest, below mountain peak, 15.369250°S, 37.061361°E, ca. 1650 m a.s.l., 21 November 2008. Captured in 2-tiered harp trap over small stream leading to large clearing in montane forest, ca. 18h00. Female adult (alcohol preserved, skull), MHNG 1971.067 (field collection number MZ261). Mozambique, Zambezia Province, Mount Namuli, camp on mountain plateau, 15.405933°S, 37.067006°E, ca. 1,200 m a.s.l., 20 November 2008. Mist netted over river in fragment of mid-altitude forest on mountain plateau, ca. 18:45 h. Reference sequences of the mitochondrial CYT-B and COI genes issued from these paratypes are deposited in the GenBank under accession numbers MZ936305 – MZ936308 and MZ936309 – MZ936312 , respectively.

Referred material.— Female adult (alcohol preserved, skull), DM 10839. Mozambique, Zambezia Province, Mount Namuli, Manho Plateau Forest, 15.3975°S, 37.0372°E, ca. 1,734 m a.s.l., 20 November 2008. Mist netted over small stream in forest clearing at approximately 18:30 h. Male adult (alcohol preserved, skull, baculum preserved in glycerol), DM 10833 (field collection number MZ099). Mount Namuli, base camp on mountain plateau, 15.405933°S, 37.067006°E, ca. 1,200 m a.s.l., 20 November 2008. Mist netted over river in remnant fragment of mid-altitude forest on mountain plateau, ca. 18:00 h. Other referred material are five specimens previously reported as R. cf. denti / simulator by Demos et al. (2019), which also proved to belong to R. namuli sp. nov. based on very similar CYT-B lineages. These specimens were collected approximatively 8 km north and 8 km east of Gurue, Mozambique (FMNH 17708–177110), in the Zovo Chipolo Forest, Nyika National Park, Malawi (FMNH 191585), and in the Ndundulu Forest, 9 km east of Udekwa Udzungwa Mts, in Tanzania.

Type locality and distribution.— Mount Namuli (15.369250°S, 37.061361°E, ca. 1,650 m a.s.l.), ca. 10 km north-west of Gurue, Zambezia Province, north-central Mozambique (central Mozambique). Recorded in montane evergreen forest and nearby forest clearings on the high plateau and below the peak of the mountain at altitudes ranging 1,220 to 1,650 m.

Etymology

The species epithet namuli is a noun in apposition and is a derivative of the type locality Mount Namuli, Zambezia Province, Mozambique.

Nomenclatural statement.—A life number was obtained for the new species Rhinolophus namuli : urn:lsid:zoobank.org:act:7A9806D9-CCC6-41A2-B898-6DCDEFFFBB51 .

Diagnosis

Medium sized bat (forearm length 47.2–49.5 mm) with medium sized ears and three well-defined mental groves on lower lip (Supplementary Appendix S2 Fig. A1 ). Horseshoe and sella wide ( Fig. 4 ), lancet concave with a narrow tip (hastate), connecting process high and rounded, with scattered hairs present along its ridge ( Fig. 5 , Supplementary Appendix S2 Fig. A2 and A 3 ). Elongated first phalanx of third digit relative to metacarpal ( Table 3 ). Bony bar forming the infraorbital foramen is present and slender, inflated nasal swellings ( Fig. 6 and Supplementary Appendix S2 Fig. A4 ), length of palatal bridge 36% of upper toothrow length ( Table 4). Minute pm3 either present or absent in the lower toothrow, with pm2 and pm4 not making contact ( Fig. 7 ). Baculum medium-sized, dorsal and ventral parts of the basal cone subequal in size with dorsal and ventral incision shallow ( Fig. 8 ). In lateral view, baculum shaft narrows towards tip, undulating in shape and forms an evenly rounded ventrally bent tip. In dorsoventral view, shaft straight with shallow constriction at inflection point of spatulated tip (Supplementary Appendix S2 Fig. A5 ). Rhinolophus namuli sp. nov. echolocates at a mean peak frequency of 76.9 kHz, SD = 0.8, range = 75.9–78.0 ( Fig. 9 and Table 5 ). Phylogenetically, this species belongs to the capensis -group.

Description

Dorsal pelage near uniform beige brown, slightly darker towards head, turning near rusty on both sides of the muzzle. Ventral fur paler than dorsal. Hair length ca. 7 mm, with dark base becoming lighter towards tips causing slight shimmering effect. At time of capture, both male and female live animals exhibited musky and somewhat unpleasant smell.

Head.—Ears medium sized, just reaching tip of muzzle when laid forward, tips pointed in holotype but bluntly rounded in both paratypes, 8–9 ear folds. Three well-developed mental grooves on the lower lip, both lips devoid of hair ( Fig. 4 and Supplementary Appendix S2 Fig. A1 ). The mental grooves were diagnosed according to Csorba et al. (2003: Fig. vi, p. xxviii) and are shown in close-up in Supplementary Appendix S2 ( Fig. A1 ). Noseleaf completely covers muzzle, horseshoe wide and secondary noseleaf absent. Sella naked, wide at base, slightly constricted in the middle but otherwise almost parallel sided with rounded tip ( Fig. 5 and Supplementary Appendix S2 Fig. A2 ). Internarial cup rather well developed. Internarial septum is not markedly expanded. Connecting process somewhat hairy, high and rounded, basal part rises near parallel to sella. Tip of the lancet is hastate, with concave sides and a pointed, tapering tip. The hastate lancet differentiates R. namuli sp. nov. from R. maendeleo and other members of the adami -group ( Fig. 5 and Supplementary Appendix S2 Fig. A2 ), more closely resembling members of the capensis -group (see Supplementary Appendix S2 Fig. A3 for a comparison of lancet shape with R. simulator ).

Wing bones.—Metacarpal of the 4th and 5th digit subequal in length, always longer than the 3rd digit ( Table 3 ). Length of the 1st phalanx greatest in 3rd digit, followed by 5th, then 4th digit. Length of the 2nd phalanx greatest in 3rd digit, followed by 4th, then 5th digit. 2nd phalanx of 4th digit greater than twice the length of 1st phalanx.

Cranium.—Skull is narrow (mastoid width exceeds zygomatic width) in MHNG 1971.068 (holotype, male), MHNG 1971.069 (paratype, female), and DM 108333 (referred material, male), but robust (zygomatic width exceeds mastoid width) in MHNG 1971.067 (♂) and DM 10839 (referred material, ♀). Differences are slight, indicating within-species variation in skull shape ( Table 4). Weakly developed sagittal crest extends roughly three quarters along the length of the braincase from well-developed supraorbital crest (sagittal crest equally developed in both male and female). Posterior-most point of skull (meeting point of lambdoid and sagittal crest) positioned markedly above the lateral plane formed by the zygomatic arches. Anterior nasal swelling inflated, moderately wide and high, angled forward and protruding anteriorly in lateral view ( Fig. 6 and Supplementary Appendix S2 Fig. A4 ). Anterior median and lateral nasal swellings well-developed but posterior median swellings deflated. Moderate rostral depression between supraorbital ridges creates a concave rostral profile. Posterior-most point of rostral depression reaches, but does not extend beyond, constriction point between the orbits ( Fig. 6 ). The infraorbital foramena are enclosed by a bony bar on both sides in all specimens collected, which is illustrated in close-up in Supplementary Appendix S2 ( Fig. A4 ). Note that in specimen DM 10833, initial inspection concluded the bar was absent on the left side (as reported by Monadjem et al., 2010 a), but subsequent investigation confirms it presence on both sides (L. Richards, personal communication). Length of the palatal bridge moderate, about one third CM3 length (34.1–37.3%).

Teeth. — Dental formula I 1/2, C 1/1, PM 2/2, M 3/3. Upper canines moderately well developed, extending about twice the length of PM4 ( Fig. 6 ). PM2 small, slightly extruded, separating C1 and PM4 and present on both sides. Minute pm3 present on left side and partly hidden by crown of pm2, lacking on right side, with pm2 and pm4 separate on both sides ( Fig. 7 ).

Baculum.—The baculum is medium-sized with a total baculum length of 2.85 mm (range ca. 2.8– 2.95 mm), greatest lateral width of basal cone of 0.78 mm and greatest dorsoventral width of basal cone of 0.87 mm ( Fig. 8 and Supplementary Appendix S2 Fig. A5 ). The basal cone occupies about 20% of the total length, with dorsal and ventral parts subequal in size, neither exhibiting a relative proximally projection. Both ventral and dorsal incisions of the basal cone are shallow. In lateral view, the baculum shaft constricts gradually, before reaching a constant width at about half the length to the tip. The shaft is not straight, but rather undulating. The tip is evenly rounded and distinctively curves ventrally at an angle of about 30° from the proximaldistal axis. In dorsoventral view, the shaft extends from the basal cone largely straight, unflattened and of equal width almost along its entire length. At the inflection point where the tip begins to curve ventrally (about 4/5th along the total baculum length), there is a shallow constriction in the shaft when viewed from a dorsoventral perspective. The tip thus appears spatulated and rounded ( Fig. 8 and Supplementary Appendix S2 Fig. A5 ).

Echolocation.—Calls recorded from seven individuals had a mean peak frequency of 76.9 kHz and a range of 75.9–78.0 kHz ( Fig. 9 and Table 5 ).

Comparisons

Taxonomic position.—The connecting process is well-developed, high and rounded, but is neither continuously arched (pearsoni -group, ferrumequinum -group or fumigatus -group), low and rounded ( hipposideros -group), low and poorly developed (maclaudi -group) nor sharply triangular ( landeri -group) ( Csorba et al., 2003). The sella is naked and constricted in the middle rather than hairy ( fumigatus -group) and/or parallel-sided (euryale - group). Three mental groves are well developed (Supplementary Appendix S2 Fig. A1 ), not partly obliterated like in members of capensis -group. These features, in addition to the characters described above, indicate R. namuli sp. nov. bears most resemblance morphologically to R. maendeleo , which was moved, with R. adami , from the capensis -group into a newly created adami -group by Kock et al. (2000). Regarding the defining characters of the adami -group, R. namuli sp. nov. has a large sella, straight-sided or rounded lancet, three well-defined mental grooves, small second premolar in the toothrow and more bulbous narial swellings. The nasal swellings are pronounced and clearly align to species of the adami - rather than capensis -group when R. namuli sp. nov., R. capensis , R. simulator and R. adami are compared side-by-side (see Supplementary Appendix S2 Fig. A6 ). However, the ear length of R. namuli sp. nov. is medium rather than large, only three of the five specimens of R. namuli sp. nov. have a narrow skull, and all have a moderate palate (36% of CM 3 in namuli sp. nov. against> 40% in adami -group). Furthermore, when viewed in profile, namuli sp. nov. has a high and rounded connecting process, which is lower and regularly arched in the adami -group ( Csorba et al., 2003). Morphologically, R namuli sp. nov. should therefore be retained within the capensis -group. Our genetic analysis confirms this, with a robust positioning of R namuli sp. nov. in the capensis -group alongside R. simulator , R. swinnyi and R. denti as closest relatives ( Fig. 3 ). Unfortunately, as no genetic sequences for R. maendeleo or R. adami are currently available, we cannot assess formally their phylogenetic position within the Rhinolophidae radiation. We therefore leave open the question of the validity of the adami -group and whether the striking morphological similarities shared between maendeleo and namuli sp. nov. represent convergences or true synapomorphies.

Specific status.— Rhinolophus namuli sp. nov. appears morphologically most similar to R. maendeleo , although these two species are currently placed in two separate groups ( capensis -group and adami -group, respectively). Due to this mismatch, R. maendeleo is used as the primary comparison to assign specific status, while other members of the adami and capensis groups are considered under ‘Similar species’ below. In comparison to R. maendeleo , R. namuli sp. nov. shares several similar external and craniodental measurements, including overlapping forearm length, horseshoe width, metacarpal length of 4th and 5th digit, length of 1st phalanx of 3rd and 5th digit, length of 2nd phalanx of 5th digit, Tib, HF, MW, ZW, BcH, CC, CM3, IOB, ML, cm3, AMSW, PL ( Table 3 ). The two species also exhibit a similar overall cranial shape and size ( Fig. 6 ). However, R. namuli sp. nov. is distinguished from R. maendeleo by a number of key characters. The characteristic feature of R. maendeleo , an absence of the bony bars forming the infraorbital foramena ( Kock et al., 2000), is not shared in R. namuli sp. nov, where the bony bars forming the infraorbital foramena are present in all collected specimens (Supplementary Appendix S2 Fig. A4 ). R. namuli sp. nov. can also be distinguished from R. maendeleo by a number of non-overlapping craniodental measurements that indicate a slightly shorter overall skull length (SL — Table 4), a slightly wider and shorter rostrum (M3M3 and PB — Table 4) and subtle differences in rostral and narial inflation shape ( Fig. 6 ). R. maendeleo also bears a deeper and longer rostral depression whose posterior most point extends beyond the constriction point between the orbits. In R. namuli sp. nov. the depression is shallower, and does not extend as far back between the orbits ( Fig. 6 ). These differences in rostrum shape, inflation angle and depression are captured in the two angle measurements (Ang1, Ang2), of which the first is non-overlapping between the species ( Table 4).

The two species also differ completely in bacular morphology ( Fig. 8 and Supplementary Appendix S2 Fig. A5 ). In lateral view, the baculum of R. maendeleo narrows gradually from the basal cone to the tip, the shaft being straight and flattened dorsoventrally, especially towards the distal end ( Kock et al., 2000). In contrast, the baculum of R. namuli sp. nov. is undulating, uncompressed, and is distinctively downturned (ventrally angled) at the tip. The inflations forming the basal cone of the baculum of R. maendeleo are unequal with the dorsal inflations protruding proximally relative to the ventral. This is in contrast to R. namuli sp. nov., which bears subequal inflations with no clear protrusion. The species also differ in the extent of the ventral incision in the basal cone, which is deep in R. maendeleo and shallow in R. namuli sp. nov. (Supplementary Appendix S2 Fig. A5 ).

Externally, the two species are distinguished by the length of the tail, size of the ears and differences in horseshoe structure, and in the dimensions of the wing bones ( Table 3 ). At a mean length of 25.9 mm, the tail of R. maendeleo is markedly longer than that of R. namuli sp. nov. (mean of 20.3 mm). Ear length follows a similar pattern (means of 23.5 mm versus 19.3 mm in R. maendeleo and R. namuli sp. nov., respectively). The connecting process of R. namuli sp. nov. is high and rounded, not continuously arched as in R. maendeleo , and with a more pronounced constriction in the sella ( Figs. 4 and 5 , and Supplementary Appendix S2 Fig. A2 ). Within the wing bones, measurements of metacarpal and phalanx length illustrate differences between the species, particularly in the 3rd and 4th digits ( Table 3 ).

Similar species. — Kock et al. (2000) compare R. maendeleo to the morphologically similar R. adami , illustrating a set of characters that differ between the species. We confirmed that R. namuli sp. nov. possesses many of the same distinguishing characters. Specifically, both R. maendeleo and R. namuli sp. nov. can be distinguished from R. adami by a smaller and concave-sided lancet, a less arched connecting process, a near-parallel sided interpterygoid groove, differing bacular morphologies, external and craniodental measurements, including palate length and inflation breadth ( Kock et al., 2000).

When compared to members of the capensis - group, R. namuli sp. nov. is larger than R. simulator , with non-overlapping forearm, tibia and wing bone lengths ( Table 3 ) and several non-overlapping craniodental measurements, such as greatest skull length, mastoid width, zygomatic width and lower toothrow length ( Table 4). Based on a comparison of published measurements of R. denti , R. swinnyi , R. gorongosae and R. rhodesiae , R namuli sp. nov. is much larger and more robust as highlighted by non-overlapping forearm length and greatest skull length. It also echolocates at a much lower frequency that any of these species (Table 2). R. namuli sp. nov. has more inflated anterior nasal swellings than members of the capensis -group (Supplementary Appendix S2 Fig. A6 ). Finally, the bacular morphology of R. namuli sp. nov. sets the species apart from all potentially similar species from the adami and capensis groups to which it bears closest morphological affinity.

Summarizing the differences highlighted above, the PCA results comparing R. namuli sp. nov. to both R. maendeleo and R. simulator (the two most similar species from the adami and capensis groups, respectively) illustrate the distinct position of the three species ( Fig. 2 ). While 95% confidence intervals (CIs) for the first two PCs overlap slightly between R. namuli sp. nov. and R. simulator , such uncertainty is to be expected given the small sample size. For R. maendeleo , the sample size was too small to estimate CIs. The first two PCs explained a large amount of variance in the data, with a cumulative 76% for craniodental measurements and 82.2% for external measurements.

Phylogenetic reconstructions based on the CYT-B gene ( Fig. 3 ) demonstrate that R. namuli sp. nov. belong to the capensis -group with strong support. Compared to the closely related and sympatric R. simulator , R. namuli sp. nov. is genetically distinct, confirming the morphological differences presented above. In the future, additional studies on the phylogenetic relationships between the species of the adami - and capensis -group would be desirable to ascertain relationships or test their taxonomic validity.

Rhinolophus namuli sp. nov. echolocates at a frequency that is not shared by other species in the region ( Table 5 ). At a mean frequency of 76.9 kHz, the calls of R. namuli sp. nov. differs markedly from R. simulator (86 kHz), R. clivosus (80.5–81.3 kHz) and R. fumigatus (58.4 kHz), the three most similarly echolocating species in our dataset for the region ( Table 5 ).

Figures

FIG. 1. Regional overview (A) and zoom in of the study area on Mount Namuli (B), showing specimen collection sites and extant montane forest and woodland cover, overlaid onto a hillshade DEM (SRTM, 90 m resolution)

FIG. 4. Live photographs of R. namuli sp. nov. in the field (♀, MHNG 1971.067), illustrating pelage colour and features of the (a) head and ears, (b) sella and lips and (c) connecting process

FIG. 5. Head shape (a and b) and noseleaf (c and d) of holotypes of R. maendeleo SMF 79.643 and R. namuli sp. nov. MHNG 1971.068, respectively; connecting process of R. maendeleo SMF 79.643 (e), SMF 99.760 (f), and of R. namuli sp. nov. MHNG 1971.068 (g)

FIG. 2. PCA biplot for selected (A) craniodental and (B) external measurements. Ellipses represent 95% confidence intervals around each species group (not possible for R. maendeleo due to the low sample size). Large symbols represent the species mean value. Percentage values on each axis are the variances explained. For specimen accession numbers and input data, see Tables 3 and 4

FIG. 3. Maximum likelihood tree based on CYT-B sequences and reconstructed with IQ-tree. Sequences of R. hipposideros were used as outgroups. Bootstrap support levels are explained in the box; the scale indicates nucleotide substitutions per site. Newly sequenced taxa are associated with their GenBank accession numbers (see Table 2 and Supplementary Appendix S3 for more details), while the species groups to which they belong appear to the right of the tree. The clade representing the new species (sp. nov.) is highlighted in grey

FIG. 6. Cranium in dorsoventral (top), lateral (middle) and ventrodorsal (bottom; only for MHNG 1971.168) views of holotypes of R. namuli sp. nov. (left) and R. maendeleo (right)

FIG. 7. Mandibles of the holotype of R. namuli sp. nov.

FIG. 8. Baculum of the holotype (MHNG 1971.168) of R. namuli sp. nov. in dorsal-ventral (a), ventral-dorsal (c), lateral (b and d) and proximal-distal (g) views. Baculum of the DM 10833 also shown in dorsal-ventral (e) and lateral (f) view. For the holotype (MHNG 1971.168), total baculum length is ca. 2.85 mm, greatest lateral width of basal cone is 0.78 mm and greatest dorsoventral width of basal cone is 0.87 mm

FIG. 9. Echolocation call of R. namuli sp. nov. (X, MHNG 1971.067; recorded at Mount Namuli, Zambesia Province, Mozambique, -15.405933 / 37.067006, ca. 1,200 m a.s.l.)