Monostaechas fisheri Nutting, 1905

Galea, Horia R. & Maggioni, Davide, 2020, Plumularioid hydroids (Cnidaria: Hydrozoa) from off New Caledonia collected during KANACONO and KANADEEP expeditions of the French Tropical Deep-Sea Benthos Program, European Journal of Taxonomy 708, pp. 1-58 : 38-44

Monostaechas fisheri Nutting, 1905

Figs 16A , 17 A–I, 18; Table 8

Monosteachas fisheri Nutting, 1905: 952 , pl. 5 fig. 3, pl. 12 fig. 8.

Monostaechas fisheri – Bedot 1921a: 6. — Stechow 1925: 252, 253. — Vervoort 1968: 64. — Migotto 1996: 50–51. — Schuchert 1997: 127, fig. 46.

Monostaechas quadridens – Ansín Agís et al. 2009: 53 , fig. 9. —? Park 2010 (pro parte): 134, fig. 75a. — Watson 2011: 18 , fig. 9 [non Monostaechas quadridens (McCrady, 1859) ].

Monostaechas sp. – Ansín Agís et al. 2009: 54, fig. 10.

non Monostaechas fisheri – Bedot 1921b: 9. — Vannucci 1949: 252, pl. 3 figs 51–54; 1950: 90, pl. 1 fig. 6; 1951: 106, 108, 112, 114. — Von Schenck 1965: 909, figs 3d, 9 [all = Monostaechas quadridens (McCrady, 1859) ].

non Monostaechas fisheri var. simplex Billard, 1913: 16 , fig. 7, pl. 1 fig. 10 [= Monostaechas quadridens (McCrady, 1859) ].

non Monostaechas fisheri var. simplex – Van Praët 1979: 914, fig. 7, pl. 1 fig. 10 [= Monostaechas quadridens (McCrady, 1859) ].

Material examined

PACIFIC OCEAN • 1 small colony with stems up to 1.5 cm high, some bearing simultaneously ♂ and ♀ gonothecae; off New Caledonia, stn DW4768; 23°25′ S, 168°01′ E; 180–210 m; 27 Aug. 2016; KANACONO leg.; MNHN-IK-2015-606 • 5 stems up to 2 cm high, some with ♀ gonothecae; off New Caledonia, stn CP4688; 22°29′ S, 167°31′ E, 278–353 m; 14 Aug. 2016; KANACONO leg.; MNHN-IK-2015-607 .

Additional material

PACIFIC OCEAN • variety with shallow hydrothecae and long lateral nematothecae: 1 fertile colony, with stems up to 3 cm high; off New Caledonia, stn DW4725; 22°41′ S, 167°05′ E; 240–256 m; 20 Aug. 2016; KANACONO leg.; MNHN-IK-2015-605 .

Comparative material

CARIBBEAN SEA • 1 profuse, fertile colony of Monostaechas quadridens McCrady, 1859 , on Sargassum sp.; France, Martinique, Anses d’Arlet; 14°29′ N, 61°05′ W; 6–10 m; 29 Jan. 2012; HRG-0853 .

Description

Colonies upright, up to 2 cm high, coplanar, rigid, with thick, brown perisarc, arising from creeping, branching, slightly flattened hydrorhiza. Stem monosiphonic; proximal part straight, irregularly divided into few internodes of varied length by means of transverse nodes; distalmost nodes with two parallel, closely-set rows of frontal nematothecae; remainder of stem divided into regular internodes by transverse nodes; each internode moderately long, straight, bearing one or two lateral apophyses and 4–6 frontal nematothecae in two closely-set rows; apophyses subterminal on internodes; when two of these are present on same internode, either opposite or subopposite; two types of apophyses: first type very short, ending in straight node and bearing secondary stem, and second type comparatively longer, ending in oblique node and bearing cladium; first regular thecate stem internode with either pair of dissimilar apophyses, one bearing secondary stem, the other a cladium, or with pair of apophyses supporting two secondary stem; in the latter case, following internode may bear two dissimilar apophyses; remainder of stem internodes with single apophyses supporting cladia only, distal part of stem assuming scorpioid shape, typical of genus. Secondary stems, like main stem, divided into regular internodes, each bearing nematothecae and upwardly-directed apophysis supporting cladium; consequently, all their cladia point upwards with respect to colony, and their hydrothecae all facing towards main stem. All cladia borne directly on main stem have their hydrothecae facing downwards in proximal part of colony and, as stem curves away in scorpioid manner, hydrothecal apertures of more distal cladia increasingly facing outwards or even upwards, depending of length of distal part of stem and number of cladia it bears. Cladia up to 8 mm long, heteromerously divided into hydrothecate and ahydrothecate internodes; up to 10 hydrothecate internodes per cladium, relatively short, each with proximal node oblique and distal node transverse, bearing hydrotheca in middle and its complement of nematothecae: one mesial, a pair of laterals, as well as axillar one on one side of hydrotheca; hydrotheca deep, tubular, half adnate, free adaxial wall and abaxial wall nearly straight, aperture circular, rim smooth; all nematothecae movable and bithalamic; laterals conical, borne on conspicuous apophyses, whole set reaching hydrothecal rim; upper chamber of lateral nematothecae lowered on adaxial side, and there with sinusoid margin. Cladial ahydrothecate internodes of varied length, with proximal node straight and distal node oblique, each bearing frontal nematotheca proximally. Stems either mono- or dioecious; gonothecae sexually dimorphic, borne exclusively on cladia by means of 2-segmented pedicel, given off laterally between base of hydrotheca and its mesial nematotheca; female gonothecae large, piriform, slightly flattened laterally, distally truncate and there with broad, thickened, ovoid aperture, proximally with 2–3 nematothecae; male gonothecae, comparatively smaller, ovoid, circular in transverse section, distally with small, rounded aperture, proximally with a nematotheca.

Remarks

The illustrations and measurements provided by Ansín Agís et al. (2009) leave little doubt that their material is conspecific with that dealt with herein. Although they identified it as M. quadridens (McCrady, 1859) , it could be demonstrated that they are specifically distinct. Indeed, Caribbean specimens ( Galea 2010), corresponding strictly to earlier descriptions of McCrady’s species, are more delicate in appearance and build exclusively scorpioid sympodia, while the present material is composed of comparatively stronger colonies with distinct, upright, straight main stems ( Fig. 17J ).

Monostaechas fisheri is still a poorly-known, seldomly-recorded species. Speculations on its affinities with M. quadridens often provided inconclusive or cautious opinions (e.g., Stechow 1925; Vervoort 1968; Migotto 1996; Schuchert 1997), although some authors pleaded for a definitive inclusion in its synonymy (e.g., Leloup 1937; Watson 2011).

Schuchert (1997) reexamined the type of M. fisheri and provided a comprehensive description and illustrations of it. It is mainly characterized by the presence of a definite, straight main stem, a peculiar mode of branching, with secondary stems arising singly or forming opposite pairs with a cladium (see also Nutting 1905: pl. 5 fig. 3). No such branching pattern is known to occur in M. quadridens , although the existence of dichotomously-branched colonies (e.g., Allman 1877: pl. 22 figs 1–5, as M. dichotoma ; Nutting 1900: pl. 13 fig. 1; Vervoort 1968; Hirohito 1974: fig. 16d; Calder 1983; Hirohito 1995: fig. 84b) is not uncommon, while the occurrence of aberrant secondary stems ( Hirohito 1995: fig. 84a) is a rare, peculiar condition.

Unlike the present material from New Caledonia, the cladial ahydrothecate internodes of the type material of M. fisheri possess two nematothecae instead of only one, although no other differences could be noted between them. It is thus assumed that the present material is, with little doubt, conspecific with M. fisheri . Supporting this hypothesis, Watson (2011, as M. quadridens ) noted the presence of 1–2 nematothecae in her specimens, with distinct stems that could probably be assignable as well to Nutting’s (1905) hydroid. Their color in life was “dark purplish grey”, thus different from the paleyellow colonies of M. quadridens from the Caribbean collected by Galea (2010). Although Watson argued that her Australian material was indistinguishable from a colony of M. quadridens from Sapelo Island, GA, USA, no information, notably on the condition of the stem, was provided to support her statement.

Only male gonothecae, bearing a single basal nematotheca, have been documented in M. fisheri ( Schuchert 1997) . The present material also possesses female gonothecae, of a much larger size compared to those of M. quadridens , and bearing 2–3 basal nematothecae, further supporting the specific separation between these species. Similar gonothecae were reported upon by Watson (2011: fig. 9e).

Specimens in material MNHN-IK-2015-605 show a more complex branching pattern of the main stem, with an increasing number of ramifications per site, and the formation of up to third order stems. Some examples of branching are illustrated in Fig. 18 . This appears to be a variety of the nominal species, distinguished by its proportionally smaller and shallower hydrothecae and longest (trumpet-shaped) lateral nematothecae, the other morphological characters, including the shape and size of gonothecae of both sexes, being similar to those of the nominal species.

A series of records attributed to M. fisheri are, most probably, based on misidentifications. Indeed, the Cape Verde material studied by Bedot (1921b) is said to exhibit all characters of M. fisheri var. simplex Billard, 1913 , which is now recognized as the simplest mode of colony growth met with in McCrady’s hydroid (e.g., Schuchert 1997).

Additionally, Vannucci’s (1949, 1950) material reportedly comprised both simple and ramified stems, although their mode of branching was not described in detail. On the account of their geographical occurrence and the size of their female gonothecae with respect to the hydrothecae ( Vannucci 1950: pl. 1 fig. 6), it is believed that she actually had specimens of M. quadridens . Migotto (1996) agrees that “Vannucci’s description (1949) of M. fisheri […] clearly conforms with the current conception of M. quadridens ”.

The colony illustrated by Park (2010: fig. 75a, as M. quadridens ) shows a peculiar branching pattern, approaching the condition met with in the present species, and both could be conspecific. However, her description fits the classical concept of M. quadridens , as well as the size of the illustrated gonothecae ( Park 2010: fig. 75b, d) do, but, since many colonies were available, it is conceivable that some belonged to one species, while some others to the second one.

Distribution

Hawai’i ( Nutting 1905),? Korea ( Park 2010), Australia ( Watson 2011), New Caledonia ( Ansín Agís et al. 2009; present study), Chesterfield Islands and Philippines ( Ansín Agís et al. 2009).

Figures

Fig. 16. A. Monostaechas fisheri Nutting, 1905, two colonies from sample MNHN-IK-2015-605. — B. Thamnopteros uniserius Galea gen. et sp. nov., holotype colony, MNHN-IK-2015-611. Scale bars: 1 cm.

Fig. 17 (opposite page).A–B. Monostaechas fisheri Nutting, 1905,stem internodewith proximal portionof cladiumbearing a female gonotheca, from sample MNHN-IK-2015-607 (A); male gonothecafrom sample MNHN-IK-2015-606 (B). — C–I. Monostaechas fisheri Nutting, 1905, morphotype with shallower hydrothecae and longer lateral nematothecae: stem internode with proximal portion of cladium (C); lateral and axillar nematothecae from one side of a hydrotheca, seen laterally (D); axillar nematotheca occurring either singly (E) or in pairs (F), and detail of a theca seen from its adaxial side (G); male (H) and female (I) gonothecae; all from sample MNHN-IK-2015-605. — J. Monostaechas quadridens (McCrady, 1859), stem internode with proximal portion of cladium bearing a female gonotheca, from sample HRG-0853, for comparison. Scale bars: A–C, H–J = 300 µm; D–G = 100 µm.

Fig. 18. Monostaechas fisheri Nutting, 1905, morphotype with shallower hydrothecae and longer lateral nematothecae: patterns of branching. Slender lines represent cladia, thicker lines show primary, secondary or tertiary stems; dots correspond to the hydrothecae.